WHY IS “TITLE 42” STILL WITH US?

 

                                    …President Biden has struggled with Title 42

 

“Title 42” was a “Pipe Dream from President Donald Trump”

 

What is Title 42?

Title 42 is a federal health order from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that cites the pandemic as a public health reason to bar people from entering the United States.

This title allows the government to send migrants back to their home countries immediately upon apprehending them.

Previously, these migrants would be held in detention facilities and charged with immigration offenses. But many hoped to request asylum proceedings to plead their case that they be allowed to stay. And given the backlog of asylum cases, they could be allowed to live in the country legally for several years while they waited for their case to go through the courts.

With Title 42, migrants get removed from the country after they are caught by the Border Patrol, and they aren’t allowed to request asylum proceedings.

President Donald Trump had implemented Title 42 in March 2020, as the pandemic was just taking off.

The Biden administration has kept it in place, although some immigration and civil rights activists have chipped away at it in court. Border crossings, and apprehensions, went from their lowest point when Title 42 was implemented, to some of the highest levels ever. (Border crossings rose because, under Title 42, migrants are expelled without a mark on their record.)

Even as President Biden has promised a more compassionate approach to immigration, the president has kept in place Title 42.  It is one of the most contentious policies of the Trump era.  Now Biden’s administration has planned to phase-out the title by this May.  This will be a win for liberal immigration activists, a number of Democrats in Congress and even some critics of the policy in Biden’s administration.

But lifting the policy could swell the border with migrants who view it as an easier way to come to the United States and claim asylum.

Why is Title 42 controversial?

Some reasons:

Activists argue this is an inhumane way to treat people seeking refuge. American law says people who come to the border to seek asylum should be allowed to. And they argue it violates the international principle of not sending people back to countries where they might be persecuted.

Also, migrants’ country of origin may not be their current home.

Last summer, during a surge of Haitian migrants at the border (for a variety of reasons, including the pandemic, political upheaval and a worsening global economy), the Biden administration used Title 42 to send many back to Haiti.  But for a number of these migrants, who had been living and working in Brazil or Chile or other South American countries for years, their home wasn’t in Haiti anymore.

In September, the U.S. special envoy to Haiti resigned in protest over this practice. “I will not be associated with the United States’ inhumane, counterproductive decision to deport thousands of Haitian refugees and illegal immigrants to Haiti, a country where American officials are confined to secure compounds because of the dangers posed by armed gangs in control of daily life,” Daniel Foote wrote.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) sued the Biden administration, and a federal judge ruled that the government couldn’t send entire families back home under this edict, limiting its impact mostly to single adults trying to cross the border.  In March, a federal court said the Biden administration could keep using Title 42, but they couldn’t send people back to countries where they would face persecution, “citing ‘stomach-churning evidence’ that the U.S. government has delivered people to places where they face rape, torture and even death,” reported The Washington Post’s Maria Saccheti and Nick Miroff.

Why did the Biden administration decide to keep Title 42 in place for so long?

The Biden administration framed Title 42 as “being temporary.”  But as recently as January, it argued in court that the policy is necessary to protect public health and stop the coronavirus from spreading along the border.

But that argument became less tenable as vaccines became easier to come by, and coronavirus cases dropped. “At this point, it’s become nearly impossible to justify Title 42,” said Jessica Bolter of the nonpartisan Migration Policy Institute (MPI)

Left unspoken is that lifting Title 42 will probably create chaos at the border.

It could implicitly encourage migrants to come and seek asylum.

Biden has struggled politically with the U.S. border.

Attempted crossings spiked as he took office, under the belief that he would be more lenient to migrants than Trump. As a result, immigration was one of the dark spots in Biden’s polling early on in his administration. We’ve already seen some troubling images arise from crowded border situations, like that of a White, Border Patrol agent on horseback trying to catch Haitian men.

“I was horrified by what I saw,” Homeland Security Secretary, Alejandro Mayorkas said at the time.

Now, as they gear up for the midterm elections, Republicans regularly describe the border as being “out of control”.  Yet another example of how Biden promised to restore normalcy to the nation, but so far, he’s delivered total dysfunction.

Ms. Bolter of the MPI, worries that an increase in border crossings could send an influx of migrants to communities along the U.S.-Mexico border that aren’t prepared to handle them. 

That issue could make it even more difficult for the federal government to process future migrants in an orderly way.

Copyright G. Ater 2022